YouTube Apple Podcast Rumble Gettr Locals

President Trump Is Skewered For Acknowledging Columbus Day

By Hannah Bleau · October 8, 2018

I was standing in line at a store the other day and overheard a conversation between two high school girls. They were talking about their three day weekend and feeling a little bit guilty about having Monday off, because Christopher Columbus was a RAVENOUS MURDERER who HATED INDIANS. One of them was all, “Yeah, so like Christopher Columbus like was a mass murderer or something, so I don’t know why we celebrate the day LOLZ.”

I looked at my mom and said, “That’s public education for ya.”

I don’t know about you, but I’m reeeeeeeeeally tired of revisionist history. Christopher Columbus didn’t sail over to the Americas with the bloodthirsty intent to murder whoever was occupying lands he’d “discover.” That’s all rooted in the really stupid belief that Native Americans lived in complete harmony with each other. That’s absolutely false. Many of them HATED each other. They were rivals who slaughtered entire villages. The Aztecs were RUTHLESS. So PLEASE. Take that “they all lived in harmony” narrative and kindly shove it.

I really like how National Review summed it up.

Let us dispense with any pretense that the indigenous peoples of the Americas lived in a peaceful idyll in harmony with their neighbors and with nature, and that the advent of Columbus destroyed a noble paradise. The great civilizations of the Western Hemisphere were indeed advanced, and yet, like Europeans, Asians, and Africans, the American peoples used their technology to subjugate. Anyone familiar with the expansionist and warlike cultures of the Aztec and Inca Empires should know that the tables would have been turned had it been the New World that “discovered” the Old and possessed the power to conquer it. Human nature, tainted with original sin, is what it is and has been — of that we can be certain.

Europeans, beginning with Columbus, treated the Indians pitilessly — that should not be whitewashed or forgotten — but, in the same way, we should not ignore the genuine good that has come down to us as a result of the course of human events — namely, the space for a unique idea to grow and flourish: the self-government of a free people, with an ever-expanding idea of who can partake of that promise.

How much is Columbus personally responsible for all of this — for the good and the ill? Only as much as any one man can be.

How much is Columbus personally responsible for all of this — for the good and the ill? Only as much as any one man can be. As the historian William J. Connell has written, “What Columbus gets criticized for nowadays are attitudes that were typical of the European sailing captains and merchants who plied the Mediterranean and the Atlantic in the 15th century. Within that group he was unquestionably a man of daring and unusual ambition.”

Connell concluded that “what really mattered was his landing on San Salvador, which was a momentous, world-changing occasion such as has rarely happened in human history.”

I’d also like to note that on Columbus Day, we’re not celebrating HIM as person. We’re not celebrating genocide or racism. The day marks a significant event. Big difference.

The current Columbus Day narrative only tells half of the story. It’s revisionist history. It’s all rooted in Western guilt.

ANYWAY. Trump tweeted about Columbus and got slammed on Twitter.

Right. Because Trump is ALSO all those things. Duh.

And so on.

Le sigh.

CHICKS ON THE RIGHT

Join the Conversation

0 comments

Share your perspective and reply to other readers.

Free account. You will stay on this page.
Be the first to comment.
More From Chicks on the Right